Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

Hours & Location

1609 2nd Avenue,
New York, NY 10028
212-734-4300
info@caledoniabar.com

Mon-Thu 5:00 pm - 2:00 am

Fri-Sat 4:00 pm - 4:00 am

Sun 4:00 pm - 12:00 am

Menus

Spirits

Ardbeg 10 Islay, 46% $18

Ardbeg 13, The Harpy's Tail Islay 46% $29

Ardbeg Wee Beastie Islay, 47.4% $16

Ardmore, Highlands, 46% $17

Benriach 10 The Smoky Speyside, 40% $20

Smoky & Peaty

  • Ardbeg 10

    Islay, 46%

    $18

  • Ardbeg 13, The Harpy's Tail

    Islay 46%

    $29

  • Ardbeg Wee Beastie

    Islay, 47.4%

    $16

  • ​Ardmore,

    Highlands, 46%

    $17

  • ​Benriach 10 The Smoky

    Speyside, 40%

    $20

  • ​Benriach 10 The Smoky

    Speyside, 40%

    $20

  • ​Bowmore 12,

    Islay, 40%

    $16

  • ​Bowmore 15,

    Islay, 43%

    $24

  • ​Bowmore 18

    Islay, 43%

    $37

  • Bowmore 25

    Islay, 43%

    $93

  • Caol Ila 12

    Islay, 43%

    $21

  • ​Highland Park 12

    Islands, 40%

    $17

  • ​Jura 10

    Islands, 40%

    $16

  • ​Kilchoman Loch Gorm

    Islay, 46%

    $27

  • Kilchoman Machir Bay

    Islay, 46%

    $18

  • ​Kilchoman Sanaig,

    Islay, 46%

    $20

  • Lagavulin 8

    Islay, 48 %

    $22

  • Lagavulin 11

    Islay, 46%

    $23

  • Lagavulin 16

    Islay, 43%

    $23

  • ​Laphroaig 10

    Islay, 40%

    $19

  • ​Laphroaig 25

    Islay, 51.29%

    $105

  • ​Laphroaig Quarter Cask

    Islay, 48%

    $22

  • Laphroaig Select

    Islay, 40%

    $18

  • Oban 14

    Highlands, 43%

    $22

  • Octomore 14.1

    Islay, 59.6%

    $40

  • Port Askaig

    Islay, 45.8%

    $17

  • ​Port Charlotte 10

    Islay, 50%

    $21

  • ​Talisker 10

    Islands, 45.8%

    $19

  • ​Talisker 18

    Islands, 45.8%

    $35

Fragrant & Floral

  • ,Cardhu Gold Reserve

    Speyside, 40%

    $15

  • Cardhu 12

    Speyside, 40%

    $20

  • Glen Grant 12

    Speyside, 40%

    $20

  • ​Glenkinchie 12

    Lowlands, 43%

    $19

Malty & Dry

  • Arran 10

    Islands, 46%

    $18

  • Auchentoshan American Oak

    Lowlands, 40%

    $15

  • Auchentoshan 12

    Lowlands, 40%

    $17

  • Glen Garioch 12

    Highlands, 48%

    $21

  • Glen Garioch Reserve

    Highlands, 48%

    $18

  • Lochlea Harvest

    Lowland, 46%

    $20

  • Lochlea Sowing

    Lowland, 48%

    $17

Rich & Round

  • Arran Barrel Reserve

    Islands, 43%

    $17

  • Aberlour 18

    Speyside, 43%

    $33

  • Aberlour A'Bunadh

    Speyside, 60.9%

    $26

  • Auchentoshan Three Wood,

    Lowlands, 43%

    $20

  • Bunnahabhain 12

    Islay, 46.3%

    $18

  • Dalmore 15

    Highlands, 40%

    $34

  • Dalmore 18

    Highlands, 43%

    $56

  • Dalmore 25

    Highlands, 42%

    $200

  • Dalmore Cigar Malt

    Highlands, 44%

    $33

  • Dalmore King Alexander III

    Highlands, 44%

    $55

  • GlenAllachie 8

    Speyside, 46%

    $18

  • Glendronach 12

    Highlands, 43%

    $19

  • Glendronach 15

    Highlands, 43%

    $30

  • Glenfarclas 10

    Speyside, 40%

    $17

  • Glenfarclas 17

    Speyside, 43%

    $32

  • ​Glenmorangie Quinta Ruban, Highlands, 46%,

    $19

  • Glen Moray Port Cask

    Speyside, 40%

    $14

  • GlenRothes 12

    Speyside, 40%

    $20

  • GlenRothes 18

    Speyside, 43%

    $39

  • Highland Park 18

    Islands, 43%

    $33

  • Jura 18

    Islands, 44%

    $30

  • Macallan 12

    Speyside, 40%

    $22

  • Macallan 15

    Speyside, 43%

    $32

  • Macallan 18

    Speyside, 43%

    $64

  • Macallan Rare Cask

    Speyside, 43%

    $57

  • Mortlach 12

    Speyside, 43.4%

    $18

  • Mortlach 16

    Speyside, 43.4%

    $30

Fruity & Spicy

  • Aberfeldy 12

    Highlands, 40%

    $15

  • Aberlour 12

    Speyside, 40%

    $17

  • Balvenie 12 Doublewood

    Speyside, 40%

    $18

  • Balvenie 14 Caribbean Cask

    Speyside, 43%

    $22

  • Balvenie 16 French Oak

    Speyside, 47.6%

    $35

  • Balvenie 21 Portwood

    Speyside, 40%

    $55

  • Benriach 12

    Speyside, 46%

    $20

  • Benriach 16

    Speyside, 43%

    $25

  • Bruichladdich Black Art

    Islay, 45.1%

    $125

  • Bruichladdich Classic

    Islay, 50%

    $17

  • Craigellachie 13

    Speyside, 43%

    $18

  • Dalmore 12

    Highlands, 40%

    $19

  • Dalwhinnie 15

    Highlands, 43%

    $20

  • Deanston 12

    Highlands, 46.3%

    $18

  • GlenGrant 12

    Speyside, 43%

    $16

  • Glenmorangie 10

    Highlands, 40%

    $14

  • Glenmorangie 18

    Highlands, 43%

    $33

  • Glenmorangie La Santa

    Highlands, 43%

    $17

  • Glenmorangie Nectar D'or

    Highlands, 43%

    $22

  • Glenmorangie Nectar D'or

    Highlands, 43%

    $22

  • Old Pulteney 12

    Highlands, 43%

    $18

  • Scapa Skiren

    Islands, 40%

    $24

  • Tomatin 12

    Highlands, 43%

    $15

Blended Malts

A blend of two or more single malt Scotch whiskies from different distilleries

  • Copper Dog

    $13

  • Compass Box Crimson Cask

    $21

  • Compass Box Flaming Heart

  • Compass Box Nectarosity

    $20

  • Compass Box The Peat Monster

    $19

  • Compass Box The Spice Tree

    $20

  • Monkey Shoulder

    $14

Blended Scotch Whisky

A blend of one or more single malt whiskies and one or more single grain whiskies. The act of combining various single malts to a grain whisky base produces a consistent style across production seasons.

  • Chivas Regal 12 yr

    $13

  • Chivas Regal 18 yr

    $22

  • Dewars White Label

    $11

  • Great King Street

    $13

  • Famous Grouse

    $12

  • Johnnie Walker Black

    $13

Elsewhere

  • Black Bush

    Ireland

    $14

  • Bushmills 12

    Ireland

    $20

  • Iwai

    Japan

    $16

  • Green Spot

    Ireland

    $18

  • Kavalan

    Taiwan

    $25

  • Penderyn Legend

    Wales

    $17

  • Redbreast 12yr

    Ireland

    $19

  • Shibui 8 Year Sherry Cask

    $17

  • Suntory Toki

    Japan

    $14

  • Teelings

    Ireland

    $12

  • Tullamore Dew

    Ireland

    $12

  • Writers Tears

    Ireland

    $15

  • Yamazaki 12

    $40

Bourbon

  • Basil Hayden's

    $16

  • Basil Hayden's

    $15

  • Blantons

    (When available)​

    $25

  • Bulleit

    $14

  • E.H. Taylor Single Barrel

    $25

  • E.H. Taylor Small Batch

    $22

  • Elijah Craig

    $14

  • Hard Truth

    $22

  • ​Kentucky Owl 'The Wiseman'

    $25

  • Kings County Straight Bourbon

    $17

  • Kings County Peated

    $17

  • Makers Mark

    $14

  • W.L. Weller C.Y.P.B.

    $30

  • W.L. Weller Full Proof

    $30

  • W.L Weller Special Reserve

    $26

  • Willet

    $15

  • Woodford Reserve

    $14

  • Woodinville Port Cask, 15 45%, Weller C.Y.P.B.

    $30

Rye

  • Bulleit

    $14

  • Coppersea Bottled-in-Bond

    $17

  • George Dickel

    $12

  • High West Double

    $15

  • James Pepper

    1776

    $11

  • Kings County Barrel Strength Rye

    $23

  • Knob Creek

    $14

  • Michter's

    $14

  • Rittenhouse

    $13

  • Templeton

    $15

  • ​Whistlepig Piggyback 6 Year

    $15

  • Whistlepig Old World 12 year

    $30

American Whiskey

  • Bernheim Wheat

    $12

  • Jack Daniel's

    $12

  • Kings County Single Malt

    $17

  • Stranahan's

    $17

  • Westland Original

    $19

Wine

Sparkling

  • Pol Clemente "Blanc de Blanc"

    Brut | France

    $13

Rose

  • J. Bogle

    Rose | California

    $13

White

  • La Fiera

    Pinot Grigio | Veneto, Italy | 2014

    $12

Red

  • Cabernet

    Lyeth | California

    $14

  • Gravelly Ford

    Pinot Noir | California

    $13

Beer

Draught

  • Allagash White

    Belgian Style Wit Bier Portland, ME 5.2%

    $9

  • Belhaven Ale

    Scottish Ale Dunbar, Scotland 5.2%

    $9

  • Guinness

    Stout Dublin, Ireland 4.2%

    $9

  • Lagunitas Daytime IPA

    Session IPA Chicago, IL 4.0%

    $9

  • Narragansett

    Lager Rochester, NY 5.0%

    $9

  • Sierra Nevada Hazy Little Thing

    Hazy IPA Chico, CA 6.7%

    $9

  • Victory Prima Pils

    Pilsner Downingtown, PA 5.3%

    $9

  • Hudson North

    Cider Newburgh, NY 5.0%

    $9

Bottles

  • Athletic Run Wild IPA (N/A)

    $8

Tried & True

  • Espresso Martini

    Vodka, espresso, kahlua

    $16

  • Bee's Knees

    Gin, lemon juice, honey, lavender bitters

    $16

  • Penicillin

    Blended scotch, lemon, honey, ginger, laphroaig select

    $16

Seasonal

  • Pushing Up Daisies

    Cucumber infused vodka, elderflower, amaro, lemon, blanc-de-blanc absinthe rinse. Cilantro (optional)

    $16

  • Preserved Lemon Martini

    Glendalough gin, dry vermouth, preserved lemon brine

    $18

  • Pixies & Pucks

    Jasmine infused gin, maraschino, sugar snap pea syrup, lemon, honey. Milk washed.

    $21

  • Me More Cowboy Than You

    Tequila, mezcal, prickly pear cactus, grapefruit, lemon, rosemary. Carbonated.

    $16

  • Passion Project

    El Dorado 5 yr rum, velvet falernum, passion fruit, lime, bitters, cinnamon, nutmeg.

    $16

​​​Whisky Cocktails​

  • Letters From Abroad

    Mossburn 12 year, lime, honey, blanc-de-blanc

    $22

  • Currant Events

    Woodinville port cask bourbon, crème de cassis, lemon, simple syrup, angostura bitters

    $22

  • High Priestess

    Laphroaig oak select, copper & kings brandy, licor 43, Pedro Ximénez sherry, angostura bitters.

    $25

  • The Hanged Man

    Port charlotte 10 yr, Rittenhouse rye, fernet branca, demerara, angostura bitters.

    $25

  • The Hunterian

    Aberlour 12, laphroaig 10, Amargo Vallet, Pedro Ximénez sherry.

    $25

​​​Mocktails​

  • Fine and Dandelion

    Chamomile infused ritual zero gin alternative, lemon, honey, cilantro (optional)

    $12

  • Tumbleweed

    Lyre's American Malt, grapefruit, prickly pear cactus, rosemary syrup, club soda.

    $12

  • Placebo

    Lyre's American malt, lemon, honey, ginger.

    $12

Flights

  • The Confectionist

    GlenDronach 12 | Glenmorangie Sauternes | Balvenie 14

    $48

  • Up In Smoke

    Laphroaig Select | Ardbeg Wee Beastie | Bowmore 12

    $33

  • The One Percenter

    Dalmore 18 yr | Balvenie 21 | Jura 18

    $100

  • Barrel Matters

    Tamnavulin Red Wine | Glen Moray Port | Glenfarclas 10

    $30

Get Directions

Email Signup

Please check errors in the form above
Thank you for signing up for email updates!
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.