Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

Hours & Location

424 Amsterdam Avenue,
New York, NY 10024
917-388-2342
info@caledoniauws.com

Mon-Thu 5:00 pm - 2:00 am

Fri-Sat 4:00 pm - 4:00 am

Sun 4:00 pm - 12:00 am

Get Directions

Menus

Smoky & Peaty

  • Ardbeg 10

    Islay | 40%

    $18

  • Ardbeg Corryvrecken

    Islay | 57.1%

    $25

  • Ardmore Legacy

    Highlands | 40%

    $16

  • Benriach Curiositas

    Speyside | 40%

    $20

  • Bowmore 12

    Islay | 40%

    $17

  • Bowmore 15

    Islay | 43%

    $23

  • Bowmore 18

    Islay | 43%

    $35

  • Caol Ila 12

    Islay | 43%

    $20

  • Highland Park 12

    Islands | 40%

    $16

  • Jura 10

    Islands | 40%

    $16

  • Kilchoman Machir Bay

    Islay | 40%

    $19

  • Kilchoman Sanaig

    Islay | 40%

    $18

  • Lagavulin 8

    Islay | 48%

    $22

  • Lagavulin 11

    Islay | 46%

    $23

  • Lagavulin 16

    Islay | 43%

    $23

  • Laphroaig 10

    Islay | 40%

    $19

  • Laphroaig 25

    Islay | 49.8 %

    $105

  • Laphroaig 25 Cask Strength

    Islay | 57.29%

    $87

  • Laphroaig Select

    Islay | 40%

    $18

  • Oban 14

    Highlands | 43%

    $21

  • Oban Distillers Edition

    43%

    $30

  • Octomore 14.1

    Islay | 59.2%

    $40

  • Octomore 15.1

    Islay

    $42

  • Octomore 15.2

    Islay

    $50

  • Port Askaig

    Islay | 45.8%

    $17

  • Port Charlotte 10 yr

    Islay | 50%

    $21

  • Talisker 10

    Islands | 45%

    $20

  • Talisker 18

    Islands | 45%

    $35

Fragrant & Floral

  • Aberlour A'Bunadh

    Speyside | 60.9%

    $26

  • Balvenie 16

    47.6%

    $35

  • Bruichladdich Classic

    Islay | 50%

    $16

  • Cardhu Gold Reserve

    Speyside | 40%

    $18

  • Cardhu 12

    Speyside | 40%

    $20

  • Glen Grant 12

    Speyside | 40%

    $20

  • Glenfiddich 12

    Speyside | 40%

    $15

  • Glenlivet 12

    Speyside | 40%

    $14

  • Glenlivet Nadurra

    Speyside | 60.2%

    $28

  • Glen Moray 12

    Speyside | 40%

    $16

  • Invergordon 44

    Highlands | 42.2%

    $85

  • Mortlach 20

    Speyside | 43.4%

    $44

  • Tomatin 12

    Highlands | 43%

    $15

Malty & Dry

  • Auchentoshan 12

    Lowlands | 40%

    $17

  • Auchentoshan American Oak

    Lowlands | 40%

    $15

  • Glen Garioch Founder's Reserve

    Highlands | 40%

    $18

Fruity & Spicy

  • Aberfeldy 12

    Highlands | 40%

    $15

  • Aberfeldy 21

    Highlands | 40%

    $50

  • Aberlour 12

    Speyside | 40%

    $20

  • Balvenie 12 Doublewood

    Speyside

    $17

  • Balvenie 14 Caribbean Cask

    Speyside

    $21

  • Balvenie 21 Portwood

    Speyside | 40%

    $52

  • Craigellachie 13

    Speyside | 43%

    $16

  • Dalmore 12

    Highlands | 40%

    $19

  • Dalwhinnie 15

    Highlands | 43%

    $20

  • Deanston 12

    Highlands | 40.3%

    $18

  • Glendullan 12

    Speyside | 40%

    $13

  • Glenfiddich Grand Cru 23 Year

    $60

  • Glenlivet Founders Reserve

    Speyside

    $15

  • Glenmorangie 10

    Highlands | 40%

    $14

  • Glenmorangie 18

    Highlands | 43%

    $33

  • Glenmorangie Nectar D'or

    Highlands

    $22

  • Jura 18

    Islands | 44%

    $28

  • Mortlach 12

    Speyside | 43.9%

    $19

  • Mortlach 16

    Speyside | 43.9%

    $30

  • Old Pulteney 12

    Highlands | 40%

    $15

  • Scapa Skiren

    Islands | 40%

    $24

  • Tamdhu 12

    Speyside | 40%

    $19

  • Tobermory 12

    Islands | 46.3%

    $24

  • Tobermory 17 Olorosso

    Islands | 55.9%

    $40

  • Tullibardine 228 Burgundy

    Highlands

    $20

Rich & Round

  • Aberlour Casg Annamh

    Speyside | 48%

    $19

  • Auchentoshan

    Three Wood, 40%

    $22

  • Bladnoch 25

    Lowlands, 43%

    $77

  • Bunnahabhain 12

    Islay, 40.3%

    $18

  • Clynelish 14

    Highland, 40%

    $20

  • Dalmore 15

    Highlands, 40%

    $34

  • Dalmore 18

    Highlands, 43%

    $56

  • Dalmore Cigar Malt

    Highlands

    $33

  • Dalmore King Alexander III

    Highlands

    $48

  • Glendronach 12

    Highlands, 43%

    $19

  • Glendronach 15

    Highlands, 46%

    $30

  • Glenfarclas 10

    Speyside, 40%

    $16

  • Glenfarclas 17

    Speyside, 43%

    $32

  • Glenfarclas 25

    Speyside, 43%

    $50

  • Glenfiddich 18

    Speyside, 40%

    $36

  • Glenglassaugh Revival

    Highlands

    $19

  • Glengoyne 18

    Highlands, 43%

    $32

  • Glenmorangie Quinta Ruban

    Highlands

    $20

  • Glenmorangie La Santa

    Highlands

    $17

  • Glenrothes 12

    Speyside, 40%

    $20

  • Glenrothes 25

    Speyside, 43%

    $115

  • Glen Moray Port Cask

    Speyside

    $14

  • Highland Park 18

    Islands, 43%

    $32

  • Longmorn 16

    Speyside, 48%

    $40

  • Macallan 12

    Speyside, 40%

    $21

  • Macallan 15

    Speyside, 43%

    $32

  • Macallan 18

    Speyside, 43%

    $64

  • Tullibardine Sherry Cask

    Highlands

    $17

Blended Malts

A blend of two or more single malt Scotch whiskies from different distilleries

  • ​Ardray

    $16

  • Campbeltown Loch

    $18

  • ​Compass Box Orchard House

    $16

  • Compass Box The Peat Monster

    $19

  • Compass Box Spice Tree

    $20

  • Copper Dog

    $13

  • Monkey Shoulder

    $14

Blended Scotch

A blend of one or more single malt whiskies and one or more single grain whiskies. The act of combining various single malts to a grain whisky base produces a consistent style across production seasons.

  • Chivas Regal 12 yr

    $13

  • Chivas Regal 18 yr

    $22

  • Johnnie Walker Black

    $13

  • Maclean's Nose

    $14

Elsewhere

  • Brenne

    France

    $19

  • Bushmills 10

    Ireland

    $16

  • Bushmills 21

    Ireland

    $60

  • Connemara Peated

    Ireland

    $20

  • Kavalan Concertmaster Port Finish Rye

    $25

  • Kavalan Select Cask

    Taiwan

    $17

  • Kavalan Select Cask

    Taiwan

    $17

  • Green Spot

    Ireland

    $18

  • Redbreast 12yr

    Ireland

    $19

  • Rose & Coe

    Ireland

    $12

  • Suntory Toki

    Japan

    $14

  • Tenjaku

    Japan

    $20

  • Tullamore Dew

    Ireland

    $12

  • Yamazaki 12

    Japan

    $40

  • Yellow Spot

    Ireland

    $35

Bourbon

  • Angels Envy Bourbon

    $16

  • Basil Hayden's

    $16

  • Blanton's Barrel Strength

    $45

  • Blanton's Single Barrel

    $25

  • Buffalo Trace

    $13

  • Bulleit

    $14

  • Coppersea,

    $18

  • Eagle Rare 10 Year

    $17

  • Garrison Brothers Bourbon

    $18

  • Isaac Bowman Port Cask

    $20

  • Kentucky Owl Takumi Edition

    $18

  • Kings County Straight Bourbon

    $17

  • Kings County Blended Bourbon

    $15

  • Kings County Peated

    $17

  • Knob Creek

    $14

  • Legent

    $14

  • Makers 46

    $14

  • Makers Mark

    $13

  • Mashbuild

    $15

  • Rare Hare

    $22

  • Weller Antique

    $28

  • Weller C.Y.P.B

    $30

  • Weller Full Proof

    $30

  • Weller Reserve

    $23

  • Woodford Reserve

    $14

Rye

  • Angels Envy

    $22

  • Bulleit

    $14

  • Coppersea Bottled-In-Bond

    $20

  • High West Double Rye

    $14

  • Hudson Do The Rye Thing

    $15

  • James Pepper 1776

    $10

  • Jefferson's Ocean Rye

    $24

  • High West Double Rye

    $14

  • Kings County

    $19

  • Knob Creek

    $14

  • Michter's

    $14

  • Rittenhouse

    $12

  • Whistlepig 10 Year

    $22

  • Whistlepig 18 year

    $50

American Whiskey

  • Kings County American Single Malt

    $17

  • Westland Peated

    $22

Happy Hour

$2 off all draft beer

$3 off all wines

Every Day until 7pm

Any Draft Beer & a Smash Burger With Fries $15

Tuesday - Saturday Until 7pm

Beer

Draught

  • Allagash White

    Maine | 5.1%

    $9

  • Belhaven ale

    Scotland | 5.2%

    $9

  • Dale's Pale Ale

    Colorado |6.5%

    $9

  • Guinness

    Ireland | 4.4%

    $9

  • Hudson North Cider

    New York | 5%

    $9

  • Lagunitas Hazy Wonder IPA

    California | 6%

    $9

  • Jack's Abby Post Shift Pils

    Massachusetts | 4.7%

    $9

  • Narragansett Lager

    Rhode Island | 5.0%

    $8

Wine

Sparkling

  • Pol Clemente "Blanc de Blanc"

    Brut | France

    $12

    $48

White

  • La Fiera

    Pinot Grigio | Veneto, Italy | 2014

    $12

    $48

  • Wither Hills

    Sauvignon Blanc | New Zealand | 2019

    $13

    $52

Red

  • Noble Vines 337

    Cabernet | California | 2020

    $14

    $56

  • Gravelly Ford

    Pinot Noir | California | 2015

    $13

    $52

Rosé

  • Bodegas Borsao

    France | 2021

    $12

    $48

Cocktails

  • Bee's Knees

    Gin, lemon juice, honey, house-made lavender bitters

    $15

  • Cucumber Fizz

    Hendrick's gin, fever-tree cucumber tonic

    $15

  • Elderflower Gimlet

    Gin, elderflower liqueur, lime juice

    $15

  • Espresso Martini

    Vodka, cold brew coffee, mr black

    $17

  • Islay Old Fashioned

    Blended scotch, bowmore 12, angostura bitters

    $16

  • Lagroni

    Laphroaig select, sweet vermouth, campari​

    $15

  • Penicillin

    Blended scotch, lemon, honey, ginger and a bowmore 12 float​

    $15

  • Winter Sour

    Mezcal, amaro, lime

    $14

Flights

  • Up in Smoke

    Ardbeg Wee Beastie, Laphroaig 10, Port Charlotte 10, Bowmore 12

    $43

  • Finish Me Off

    Balvenie 14 (Rum Casks), Tullibardine 228 (Burgundy Cask), Dalmore 12 (Sherry Butts), Glen Moray Port Cask

    $48

  • Nether Regions

    Glen Moray 12 (Speyside), Auchentoshan 12 (Lowlands), Jura 10 (Island), Laphroaig Select (Islay)

    $38

Tuesday - Saturday


Smaller

  • House Made Potato Chips

    $5

  • Truffle Fries

    $9

  • House-Made Fried Pickles

    $8

  • Baked Pretzel Sticks

    $12

  • House-Made Ricotta

    Balsamic vinegar and toasted sourdough

    $14

  • Mozzarella Sticks

    Lightly fried and served with house marinara

    $12

  • Cajun Cauliflower

    Battered, breaded, fried and serves with buffalo sauce

    $11

Bigger

  • Chicken Tenders

    with French Fries and BBQ, sauce

    $16

  • Smash Burger

    With American cheese, caramelized onions, burger sauce, pickles, fries

    $18

  • Homemade Mac & Cheese

    3 cheese Mac and cheese baked and topped with breadcrumbs

    $16

  • Fried Chicken Sandwich

    Buttermilk marinated chicken, buffalo sauce, blue cheese ranch dressing, fries

    $18

  • Homemade Cottage Pie

    Ground beef with peas and carrots topped with fluffy parmesan mashed potatoes

Email Signup

Please check errors in the form above
Thank you for signing up for email updates!
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.